

The Number
$1,625
That's how far ahead the average HSA plan starts the year against the average PPO, for a nurse making $40 an hour who puts enough in the account to cover the deductible. It's the lower premium, the employer's deposit and the tax skipped on the nurse's own deposit, added together. A raise would need to be $1.32 an hour to take home the same amount.
Plans: KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the averages for single coverage at large employers. Take-home from Jemma's paycheck calculator, 2026 tax tables, three 12-hour shifts in Colorado, single filer. Public data, not Jemma salary data.

The Move
Count the head start before you pick a plan
Most plan comparisons start with two numbers: the premium and the deductible. On KFF's 2026 averages, the HSA plan's premium is $395 a year lower than the PPO's, and its deductible is $1,452 higher. If you stop there, the PPO looks safer.
The video adds 3 things that comparison leaves out, for one nurse at $40 an hour:
The lower premium is worth $260 after taxes. The $395 is pre-tax money, so when it stays in your paycheck, it gets taxed.
Your employer puts money in the account: $657 on average. That average includes the employers who put in nothing, so check yours.
You skip tax on your own deposit: $708. That's on $2,077 put in through your paycheck. With the employer's $657, it covers the whole $2,734 deductible.
Those add up to the $1,625. How much of it you keep depends on the year you have:
A quiet year, with preventive care only: you keep all $1,625.
A year you hit the deductible: the HSA plan's deductible costs you $1,452 more, and you finish $173 ahead.
That same year with none of your own money in the account: you lose the $708 and pay the deductible with money that's already been taxed. You finish $535 behind the PPO.
So before you pick the HSA plan, check whether you can spare the deposit. It lowers this nurse's take-home by $1,369 a year, about $53 every 2 weeks.
Your own situation moves the answer. On a PPO, a visit or a prescription is usually covered before you meet the deductible. On an HSA plan, you generally pay full price until you reach it, except for preventive care. So with care every month, the PPO can win. With a $36 copay, the average for a second-tier drug, the PPO wins once a monthly prescription costs about $171 at full price, even with the account funded.
Covering a family gives the HSA plan more room. In a deductible year, it finishes $364 ahead with no deposit and $1,271 ahead funded. And California and New Jersey can still tax the money you put in.
Two rules before you sign up. For 2027, you can put in up to $4,500 for single coverage or $9,000 for family coverage, and that includes what your employer puts in. You also can't put money in an HSA while a regular FSA covers you, and that can include your spouse's FSA.
The article has the same math in 6 states, what an FSA changes, how to compare out-of-pocket maximums, and the 5 things to pull from your benefits guide: Should a nurse pick the HSA plan or the PPO at open enrollment?
Jemma's free paycheck calculator can run your own 2 plans. Put in your base rate, your shifts and your state. Open the Add my real details section and put the PPO's monthly premium in the Health insurance premium field. If your benefits guide lists the premium per paycheck, turn it into a monthly amount first. Click the Compare scenarios button to make a copy. In the copy, change the premium to the HSA plan's and put your deposit for the year in the HSA contribution field.
The calculator shows the difference in take-home between the two, per week and per year. Use the yearly one. It has a minus sign if the HSA plan takes home less, which is expected when your deposit comes out of your pay. Add your deposit and your employer's deposit to that number to get your head start. In the example above, it reads −$1,109 a year. Add the $2,077 and the $657, and you get the $1,625. The deductible has no field, so do the last step by hand: subtract how much more your care would cost on the HSA plan in the kind of year you expect. If the extra cost is more than your head start, the PPO wins that year. Save your comparison to a free account, and once you've shared your salary, you can download it as a free Take-Home Pay Report (PDF).
The nurse and both plans are examples. The plans are averages across large employers (200 or more workers), not two plans from one employer, and 12% of workers on these HSA plans got no deposit from their employer. Money left in the account counts at face value: it's still yours, though it can only be spent tax free on medical bills. The answer for a nurse who can't fund the account is for single coverage. The family figures are for a head of household in Colorado, on plans with one deductible for the whole family. Taxes are 2026's, because the 2027 tables don't exist yet. This is general information, not financial, tax or insurance advice.

Unlock Watch
The Salary Explorer is open
Jemma passed 100 verified nurses, the count the Salary Explorer needed to open. It's at 130 as of Tuesday morning. A nurse counts once their salary is shared and their license is verified.
The Salary Explorer now shows real salaries from verified nurses in place of the samples. Anyone can see up to 5 recent salaries on a page. A nurse with a verified license can search all of them by state, specialty and credential. Each salary shows the credential, specialty, experience, pay and only as much of the location as that nurse chose to show. It never shows a name, an employer or a license number.
Closest to 30 verified nurses
Jemma publishes full pay data for a group, such as RNs in Texas, once it reaches 30 verified nurses. Texas is at 12, Ohio at 9 and Florida at 8. A week ago they were at 10, 5 and 5. The next RN in any of those states who shares a salary and has their license checked moves that state one closer.
Cell | Verified nurses | To go |
|---|---|---|
RNs in Texas | 12 of 30 | 18 |
RNs in Ohio | 9 of 30 | 21 |
RNs in Florida | 8 of 30 | 22 |

Pay News
No deal at Brigham, and the strike is still set for Thursday: the union for about 4,000 nurses at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston says it bargained from 9 a.m. Monday until around midnight without reaching an agreement. The open-ended strike is scheduled to start at 7 a.m. on Nov 12, and the union says it will return to the table at any time before then. The hospital's offer is a two-year contract with a 2.5% raise each year for nurses at the top of the pay scale, and it keeps the 5% yearly raises for nurses still moving up the 20 steps.
The health FSA limit goes to $3,500 for 2027: the IRS raised it by $100 on Nov 5. If your plan allows a carryover, the most you can carry into the next year is $700, up $20. The same release sets the 2027 standard deduction at $16,600 for single filers, $24,925 for heads of household and $33,200 for married couples filing jointly.
UI Health's advanced practice nurses could strike as soon as Nov 11: the union for 200 advanced practice nurses, physician assistants and midwives at UI Health in Chicago says they were left out of a 2% raise that other hospital staff got in August, and that they've gone two years without a raise. As of Nov 5, the union hadn't said if or when they would walk out. UI Health says a strike would be unlawful while a court order pausing bargaining is in effect.
Porter Medical Center nurses get 3.25%, 3.25% and 3.5%: the new three-year contract covers 143 nurses at the hospital in Middlebury, Vermont. Their last contract expired on Sept 30. About 70% of union members voted, and 80% of them approved it. The union's vice president told members the wage increase is "the obvious shortcoming of this contract" and wrote that "by itself, I fear it will not keep up with inflation."
AMN says demand for travel nurses is up: the staffing agency reported on Nov 5 that its travel nurse revenue was 19% higher than a year earlier. It averaged 9,486 nurse and allied travelers on assignment in the third quarter, up from 8,203. Another $59 million of revenue came from what it calls labor disruption, its staffing for hospitals during strikes. The release has no pay rates in it.

Your Turn
Which health plan are you picking for 2027?

Your Next Step
The plan figures above are for one example nurse and two average plans. Jemma is collecting what nurses are actually paid, one license-verified, anonymous salary at a time. Now that the Salary Explorer is open, each new one is a salary other nurses can search. The button below is the step that helps most from where you are now.

PS: If you've been on an HSA plan, reply and let me know how it went.
Tom
